Does Nominee Realty Trust Pass Through Probate?
Photo by Wesley Tingey on Unsplash
Question:
Do nominee realty trusts have to go through probate?
Response:
Theoretically, yes, but in practice, no. To understand this distinction, we’ll have to start with an explanation of nominee realty trusts (which are primarily used in Massachusetts).
The idea of a nominee trust is that the the trustees own title on behalf of the beneficiaries and must act at the direction of the beneficiaries. The beneficiaries are not listed in the trust document itself, but in a separate schedule of beneficiaries. For instance, if four siblings own property together, they would be listed on the schedule of beneficiaries, each owning 25%. Two of the siblings may be listed as trustees, but they could not sell the property owned by the trust unless directed to do so by the beneficiaries (by all of them or by a majority, depending on what the trust says). So, even though it’s called a nominee realty “trust,” legally it’s really an agency agreement, with the trustees acting as agents for the true owners.
This aspect of a nominee realty trust was recently clarified in a decision by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court which explains:
Therefore, the technical response to your question is that if one of the siblings dies, her 25% share would pass to her estate and would have to go through probate in order for it to go to her heirs.
But, practically, that usually does not happen. Instead, the remaining beneficiaries and the deceased owner’s heirs simply execute a new schedule of beneficiaries reflecting the new ownership interests, perhaps the three surviving siblings each continuing to own 25% each and the five children of the deceased sibling each owning 5%. This works as long as everyone agrees since the true ownership of property in nominee trusts is kept secret.
What I see in many schedules of beneficiaries, that in my view perverts the nature of nominee trusts, are attempts to do more than simply state each owner’s interest in the trust. Instead, they may say that the parents have a life interest and that after they pass away, their interest will pass to their children. This seems to be mixing trusts and agency agreements and can easily raise problems. That said, it usually works as a practical matter. Again, as long as everyone is on the same page, after the parents have both died, the children can create a new schedule of beneficiaries and no one else is the wiser.
What I also see a lot are missing schedules of beneficiaries, which can create a lot of problems. For a full discussion of this issue and nominee realty trusts in general, read my blog post here.
